Log in

04 October 2008 @ 10:41 am
challenge 1; round 1: voting  
Skipping: letoist, goodbye_anymore, turnupyourlove, iammeanttolive
No Skips Left: letoist, goodbye_anymore, turnupyourlove, iammeanttolive

» Please vote for THREE icons of lesser quality with a legitimate reason why. "I hate that brush" is not a good comment, however, "the brush does not fit with the icon" is. When voting, elaborate your reasons, be constructive. Don't feel bad, the makers want to know why you chose their icon as a least favorite and that way it can help them to improve. Make your comments a little long, not just a few words.
» Please vote for ONE icon you like the most with a legitimate reason why. "Omigosh it's so cute!" is not a good comment, however, "the text & font fits well, everything flows nicely" is. Try to elaborate your reasons the best you can, this way the maker knows what the voter's enjoy and what to improve on. Make your comments a little long, not just a few words.
» When voting, do not vote based on personal preference, base it on the quality of the icon. If your comment seems to much of a personal preference then I will ask you to reword it and possibly elaborate.
» Do not vote for yourself and do not have your friends vote for you (this is for fun for crying out loud).
» Please use the format in the textbox when voting.
» DEADLINE: Sunday » evening.

1 2 3
4 5 6

Feel free to ask any questions.
(Deleted comment)
.redhour on October 5th, 2008 07:54 pm (UTC)
Your comments seem a little on the personal preference side. Would you mind rewording them in a constructive way? Thanks. Sorry for being picky.
goodbye_anymore: heath-angelicgoodbye_anymore on October 5th, 2008 05:01 am (UTC)
ugh, I didn't realize the round had already begun!

Least Favorites:
#1: the icon has a bit of a green tint, it's a little dark
#6: the red texture doesn't really do much for the icon
#3: the blue texture doesn't really add anything to the icon, awkardly placed.

#2: I really like the textures, very original

that was hard, they're all really good!
bella.: heathbuggerfck on October 7th, 2008 03:37 pm (UTC)
Least Favorites:
2: This icon seems too busy, with the combination of the text, the blend, AND the texture.
3: The blue corner is out of place and distracting, and it doesn't really compliment the subject of the icon.
1: While I like this icon's simplicity, it's almost too simple; also, the contrast is off-balance - too dark on one side, too light on the other.

5: The texturing and the text on this icon is appropriate; they are interesting, but they're aren't TOO much, so the icon is still relatively simple.

(Sorry I didn't get to this before now! D:)